Quantcast Maguindanao carnage strikes at the very foundations of democracy - Inside Scoop

Maguindanao carnage strikes at the very foundations of democracy

| 53 Comments | No TrackBacks

By the National Union of Journalists of the Philippines (NUJP)

 

The NUJP emands justice for our colleagues and all the other victims of the November 23 carnage in Maguindanao province.

The Ampatuan massacre, which the military has confirmed was perpetrated by Shariff Aguak Mayor Andal Ampatuan Jr. and police Senior Inspector Dicay, goes beyond the issue of freedom of the press and of expression and strikes at the very foundations of democracy.

Aside from the wife, relatives and supporters of Ismail Mangudadatu, who were on their way to file his certificate of candidacy to run as governor of Maguindanao, the slaughter also claimed the lives of at least 12 colleagues, according to reports from our chapters in Mindanao.


This incident not only erases all doubts about the Philippines being the most dangerous country for journalists in the world, outside of Iraq, it could very well place the country on the map as a candidate for a failed democracy.

Running for office and voting are as much exercises of free will and expression as covering and reporting the news.

We expect nothing less from this government than the swift apprehension and punishment of everyone involved in this gruesome assault on the national body politic, including the masterminds, regardless of who they might be.

Anything less would mean that the impunity that has emboldened those who would silence the press, staining this administration with the worst record of murdered journalists, has spread to embolden those who would subvert our democracy for their own selfish interests.

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blogs.inquirer.net/cgi/mt/mt-tb.cgi/405

53 Comments

this maguindanao carnage which involve the ampatuans' are not new to us, but this is the worse. you are lucky there in Luzon since this is not happening to you, maybe it happens in some province, but the thing is this family is very close to president arroyo,I learned also two yrs ago, the governor itself chainsaw...as in... his escort and other people who are involve who traitor him. he is like god here........ anything he would say his men will follow or else they will be killed. this is not new to us....he is well known of this activities...mr. Andal ampatuan itself is the monster for this incidents... especially for the upcoming election they wanted to rule everywhere...and if you get in there way they will crushed you apart and kill all your family.... they are so powerfulll......only God can stop them..

Sila -sila nag papatayan na kapwa nila muslim ano na ang ngyari sa inyo? pati-kapwa ninyo muslim pinapatay at pati walang kinalaman sa politica na damay repoter, camera man and crews un arms...TAMA KA nelson! mass alam mo kasi taga roon ka sa mindanao.Sino pa ang maka solve ng problema diyan massacre kung ang politikong tao at pati pulis ay kasama, ano pa ang batas diba wala na? MNLF,MILF, ABUSAYEF..THEY ARE SAME DOG JUST DIFFRENT NAME..SO MATIRA MATIBAY PALA SA MUSLIM CLANS AT SIL-SILA RIN PALA. no wonder na madaming MILITARY ang na ambuse at napatay at na pugatan ng ulo. pag punta mo sa municipalities nila .eh... for sure naka tip kana .kaya kalimitan patay at hinde na maka balik ng barracks nila.ano kaya ang dapat gawain ng goverment natin? na mahalin sila dahil sigurong vote{BOTO} ang ma promises sa kanila?O mag patay- patayan na lang si GMA at it's only month away tapos na ang term niya.at sabihin ni GMA bahala na kayo.... tapos na ang term ko at nagamit ko na sila noon election.

If Gloria Arroyo fails to disarm the private armies of her political allies as reportedly demanded by G. Teodoro, the latter will have a good face-saving exit from his hopeless quest for Philippine presidency.

Marami akong kaibigan na Muslim! Pero ngayon lang ako nakarinig ng mga muslim na hindi sibilisado! Parang walang pinag aralan at walang mga puso!

Mas maraming muslim na namumuhay ng tahimik! Mga pulitiko lamang ang mga asal hayop!

Alam ng mga gumawa ng krimen na makakalusot sila dahil "dikit" sila kay Presidente ARROYO! Ito ang nagpapalakas ng kanilang loob para gumawa ng mga bagay na karumal-dumal.

Sa kanilang pagiisip, di sila pababayaan ni GMA dahil marunong itong tumanaw ng "utang na loob"! Alam naman ng karamihan ang tulong ng mga AMPATUAN kay GMA nuong 2004! Ang Maguindanao ang nagbigay ng botong kailangan ni GMA para manalo at talunin si FPJ.

Ang isa pang tinulungan ng mga AMPATUAN ay si Senador ZUBIRI. Ito ang pinanghahawakan ng mga AMPATUAN. Ang kanilang lakas sa mga namumuno! At dahil dito, nagkaron ang mga AMPATUAN ng tinatawag na..."culture of impunity"!!!

Nelson, tagalugin mo na lang sa susunod na mag comment ka.

Sakit sa mata ng Ingles mo!

I want to join the condemnation of the massacre. It is truly heartbreaking and disturbing. And along with all Filipinos, demand justice.

Please do not divide the country further by pointing to our fellow Filipinos in Mindanao or the fact that they are Muslims. Political clans and political killings happen in Luzon (Cavite, Batangas, Bulacan etc.) in any every part on the country. It starts with small acts of corruption/stealing, then politicians/officials start thingking that they are above the law, then act like gods. As usual, a good number people have to die before give it our attention.

Next year is an election, we have been doing this for more than fifty years now. We have to remind ourselves and the candidates what Democracy means. It not about the politicians, its about the people- what we want and what is good for us. We have the power, we are the boss, they are our servants. Don't put your name on government projects because that is the the public's money, wait in line like the rest of us, wait in traffic like the rest us, skip dinners if the people are hungry,and simply - obey the law.

Sooner of later something like this would happen.

After failing to do "lifestyle checks" on the Ampatuans, even if they, for the past decade, blatantly show off their wealth with numerous mansions, range rovers, hummers, land crusiers and 27 toyota hilux pickups apparently bought in cash... and come to think of it, they don't have any known businesses to connect their wealth with whatsoever...

After failing to at least reprimand the lord of this clan for breaking this punisher mayor of Davao City's simple no-smoking policy, or prudently fine the establishment who allowed him to smoke (Ampatuan apparently smoked inside Toyota Davao when he ordered the 27 hilux pickups)...

After failing, specifically by this punisher Davao mayor, to disallow the entry of this clan's illegal firearms to freely enter his city...

After failing to implement the gun-ban policy not only in Maguindanao, but throughout Mindanao as well...

After turning several blind eyes on numerous heinous crimes committed by the lords and the scions of this evil clan...

After failing to replace military and police officials who are obviously under the payroll of this family...

Sooner or later, something like this might happen.

And we wonder who is it to blame.

We are condemning a massacre here and some people have the gall to criticize Nelson's English. Nevermind na hindi sya pasado sa standards nyo importante naiintindihan naman ang ibig nyang sabihin. My heart goes to you Nelson. It must be hard to live in a place ruled by warlords.

The Ampatuans even when in Davao City are acting like they are still in their turf with all the heavily armed bodyguards in tow riding in marked PNP vehilces and a fleet of luxurious large SUVs. There have been reported abuses being done by them from disregarding traffic signs, wanton display of high powered guns in public and even murder committed by one of their kin in a popular nitespot. The city mayor of davao who the people outside of davao fancies as a tough executive always find an excuse why he cannot discipline these spoiled politician making trouble right under his noses. "Matapang lang daw si mayor sa TV program niya" is what some folks here think of the mayor. Instead of sending presidential adviser Dureza to make some compromise with Ampatuan, the government should immediately arrest him and ground him so he cannot cover his tracks in this gruesome killings. They should be disarmed and arrested immediately.

Tama na mga kaibigan,dapat kamay na bakal ang gagamitin dyan madami ang magagaling sa pilipinas kaya di pwede democrasya na tulad sa america ..dapat sa atin ay may pangulo na malamarcos style,dictador ang kailangan natin para isa lang ang magaling or sabihin mang magnanakaw ay iisa lang... may option pa tayo...go bayani fernando for president and jojimar binay sa bise...tapos ang dilg secretary ay si panfilo lacson and make joseph estrada as defense secretary.
PWEDE NA DIN SI VILLAR SA DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE AND NOYNOY AQUINO SA DFA...GORDON REMAIN AS TOURISM SECRETARY,LOREN LEGARDA SA DENR,ROXAS SA DTI,ESCUDERO SA AGRICULTURE/DAR....KURO KURO LANG KASI MAPA MUSLIM O KRISTIANO BASTA PILIPINO PAREHO LANG....

it will not be simple for witnesses to just surface and take the witness stands for as long as the Ampatuan machinery is in place, the families and friends of the witnesses are in the line of fire,,,,funny but the PNP does not even seem to acknowledge the realities of the area or the region...the don't even have the balls to pick up the Ampatans for questioning ...more so they cannot even trust their own organization!!!!mas loyal sa mga ampatuan ang PNP at military naka-assign dyan....

arroyo vows justice? what her style of justice? Hello Garci, ZTE, Joc-joc......what else is new.....

Wag naman po nating sabihin porket Muslim e ganun na ang asal. Ang totoo mapa Kristiyano ka o Muslim kapag nabahiran ka ng karumihan ng pulitika ay ganito kalalabasan mo. Ang gumawa ng mga bagay na ito ay hindi na maituturing na isang Muslim, Kristiyano or anu man sekta dahil wala na silang takot sa Maykapal. Wala ng puso at ang kaluluwa ay susunugin sa impyerno habang panahon. Kung di man nakuha hustisya dito sa lupa, huhusgahan si ng Maykapal sa mga kasalanang nagawa nila.

Totoong me part to blame ang Administration dahil kapalit ng mass votes e hinayaan nilang maghariharian ang mga to (diba eto din yung binalita dati na nambugbog sa isang golf course?). Pero ngayon e me pagkakataon si Arroyo na itama ang mali at papagbayarin ang mga me sala. Saving face ika nga.

Isa ako kapampangan at kababayan ko si Arroyo sa Lubao, we are proud of her fathers legacy. Pero sa kanya hindi, dati ok pa pero unti unti nawala ang confidence ko sa kanya, and this i might say just took off the last remaining reasons to believe her ability to govern..so sad and shamefull.

A lot of our friends from the media were killed in the butchery. Some of them hang out in the office prior to the carnage.

Atty. Cynthia Oquendo was also a good friend and a very good trial lawyer here in South Cotabato, while Atty. Connie Brizuela was a respected lawyer up North.

We have pictures of the victims which vividly show the fear and pain etched in their faces. And who said that none was decapitated?

So you can imagine how we feel right now, the rage and anger are seeping through our system.

We can never reconcile how these murderers can get away with this because apparently that is the state of things right now. They have not arrested yet even a few of the 100 armed men, how do we expect to get the mastermind?

Sure, everybody is pointing a finger to the Ampatuans. But as of this writing, PNP issued a statement that there is no evidence yet to link anyone of the Ampatuans with the massacre. It's a sick joke even for those who have not studied law.

On the other hand it was a mistake for the Philippines to have not ratified the Rome Statute because the Ampatuan Massacre is definitely covered under the International Criminal Court.

It's a crime of humanity, no amount of justification, tradition or rules of engagement, however grand or ancient that is, would rationalize this macabre.

Our country the Philippines is a country like hell. almost all government officials are corrupt. we Filipinos pay taxes. pero wala nmn magandang sinusukli ng ating gobyerno. matatapos pa ba kaya ang problema natin? sana mawala na ang katiwalian! mamatay sana kayung mga kurakot sa gobyerno!

Kung pwede lang sana gumawa ng ibang island sa may Pacific Ocean at lumipat itong mga Ampatuan at dun sila maging gobernador, presidente at kung anumang posisyong gusto nila kasi hindi naman nila mahal ang bansa natin. Puro gulo lang at sakit ng ulo ang binibigay. I bet they don't think they're Filipinos, they just think they're datus and Moros. I'm also from Mindanao at nakakainis na hindi matatapos-tapos ang mga ganitong pangyayari, MILF, MNLF, Abu Sayyaf, etc. Masama tuloy ang generalization pag sinabing Mindanao e hindi naman lahat ganun. Sa bandang Silangan ang mapapayapang probinsya, sa may Kanluran ang magugulo. Kahit ano tuloy gawin ng ibang probinsya para pumasok ang mga investors at umunlad ang Mindanao at makatulong sa bansa natin nawawalan din ng saysay.

Lahat naman ng politician sa Pilipinas warlord,,in one form or another.

As Nelson mentioned senseless killings for power were nothing new to my ear since I relocated to Mindanao particularly Cotabato. Sabi nga what comes around goes around, I hope this will be the end of the Ampatuan, and the end of all aspiring for political power who uses guns,position,money to kill just to get a seat in the government. Condolences to all who the family who lost a love one.May Allah be with them.It hurts to connote these murderers to Muslims the believer of PEACE ISLAM. Each of us are victims color, race or religion.
This is a great challenge to president Arroyo's governance cuddling murderers,corrupt officials like the Ampatuans who did nothing to improved the life of the people,yet impoverished them for God knows how many years. Must I say more??

After working so hard for so long trying to convince foreign investors and telling funders to give Mindanao (and the Philippines) a second chance, comes this most barbaric of crimes. I regret to have said the things I said and written the things I wrote trying to present the country in an improved light. Now they must be snickering behind my back and I don't mind, but for the millions of Filipinos who will have a hard time getting jobs, this is like another hole they need on their heads! Yet you can bet, in a fw months, politicians will again be all over the place, riding like goons in some Western movie, and Filipinos applauding and worshiping them as if nothing happened. What a sick and hopeless people!

Dapat putulan ng ulo ang mga perpetrators na yan parang sa Saudi Arabia and Iran pag nakagawa ng karumal dumal na krimen ang dapat parusa ay kamatayin din, wala na silang awa sa walang kalaban laban na mga journalist at sa ibang civilians.

Ang ganitong gawain ay hindi mangyayari kung walang sinasandalan ang kanilang pamilya sa MalacaƱang.

Kung si Ted Failon na suspek pa lang sa nagpakamatay na asawa niya, ilang matataas agad na opisyal ang sumugod sa kanilang tahanan para ipadakip sa hinanlang pagpaslang. Ngayon ko makikita kung gaano katapang ang mga pulis, cgte . . .sugurin nga ninyo ang mga ampatuan! Nasaan ngayon ang mga ka-pulisan? Ngayong hindi lang isang tao ang namatay bagkus ay 57 na sa huling talaan, nasaan ang tapang ninyong sugurin ang suspek para dakipin? Alin ba ngayo9n ang mas grabe, yung suspek sa nagpakamatay na asawa o yung suspek sa pumatay sa 57 katao? Aber nga, Madam President, alin ba ang mas grabe? Yung isa ang namatay o yung 57? Bakit ilang araw na ang nakalipas pero wala pa kayong nadadakip. Puro lang press release na bibigyan ng hustisya! Kesyo walang kinikilingan at walang sinisino ang batas. Pero nonng tungkol kay Ted Failon, hindi nga nagtagal ng kalahating araw at overkill pa ang pag-aresto. NGAYON NINYO IPAKITA MGA PULIS KAYO ANG TAPANG NINYO. NAKAKAHIYA KAYO! ILANG ARAW NA ANG NAKAKALIPAS, PURO PA IMBISTIGASYON. PWE!

You filipino's are so compliant with all of this. You complete indifference for your corrupt political system is pathetic. This massacre is by the people of the Philippines on themselves. You mix your warped catholic beliefs so strongly in your government that of course the muslims want to strike back. How do they feel with these Immoral and sinful hypocritical catholics in their face. Violence is not the answer but seriously pinoys. Its your OWN FAULT!!

Di na ito bago sa pilipinas, sensationalized lang kasi nasa bagong henerasyon!

part na kultura natin.kung babalikan natin ang kasaysayan ng pilipinas umiikot na parang gulong. ika nga sa kasabihan "HISTORY REPEAT ITSELF".

KARUMAL-DUMAL IYAN ANG MAIPAPALIWANAG NG KARAMIHAN.

HUSTISYA- MATAGAL NANG PANAHON WALA SA ATIN IYAN.
KAHIRAPAN- LAGANAP SA KAPULUAN.
KALASWAAN- PORNOGRAPIYA" FILIPINA CAM GIRLS". ILANG LIBONG FILIPINA NAGBEBENTA SA PAMAMAGITAN NG MODERNONG PAG-AALIW.
KAMANGMANGAN SA KAPWA FILIPINO. EDUKASYON PINAGKAKAIIT NG GOBYERNO.

HANGGA't MAY GANID at POOT sa kalooban ng kapwa pilipino hindi natin makakamtam ang tunay na diwa ng demokrasya!

Naniniwala pa rin tayo na laging MAY BUKAS PA!

at MAY NATITIRANG PA RING MGA PILIPINO NA BUSILAK ANG KALOOBAN!

NANINIWALA PO TAYO NA LAGING MAY PAG-ASA ANG BUHAY.

ITO PONG MGA UNOS NA NARARANASAN NG ATING KAPWA PILIPINO AY MAY KAHIHITNAN DIN.

KAMI PO AY NAKIKIRAMAY SA MGA NAULILA AT MGA PAMILYA.

NAKIKIRAMAY DIN PO KAMI SA MGA KAMAG-ANAK NG MGA MAMAHAYAG NA PINASLANG.

NANINIWALA PO TAYO NA MAS MALUPIT ANG HUSTISYA NG PANGINOON.

WHAT KIND OF DEMOCRACY DOES THE PHILIPPINES HAVE? EVEN THE FAMILY IDIOT IS BEING "ELECTED". THERE ARE A LOT OF RUMORS ABOUT YOUNG GIRLS BEING ABDUCTED BY HIS THUGS. IT TURNS OUT HE IS ALSO A PEDOPHILE.

The Ampatuans are not MUSLIMS! they are more than 'kafirs' and should be condemned till the lasts of their generations! The number of places they named in their (dis)honor should even be recalled by Congress and obliterated from the Phil. map to spare the good citizens from bearing a stigma of the "devil-incarnate". As a 'president', GMA will be giving a small favor to other good 'Macapagals' if she can do what is necessary to let this 'monsters' answer for this unimaginable carnage! Lest GMA goes down in country's history as Great Mastermind of the Ampatuans...

The government again showed its insensitivity to public outrage. What else can we expect. The drama of presenting the suspect to the media flopped since the mastermind was not handcuffed and properly restrained contrary to the pronouncement of the Secretary of Injustice. He might as well spend his 36 hours in the guest house of the Palace.

accountability in the ampatuan massacre should go to the highest levels of the philippine government...the brazenness and sheer impunity of the act must be sanctioned by the military and the police from a higher command...the political and military leadership should be held accountable by virtue of command responsibility...the evidence is there...to toto maguddatu.....justice still would not be served if and when the mastermind and his cohorts are jailed.... those responsible for the environment that could allow an act of this magnitude to be perpetrated should also be brought to the bars of justice....

dominica gunnawa
216 little oaks terrace. gansevoort, ny 12831

GMA, wake up! if ikaw ang nasa sitwasyon ng mga namatayan ano gagawin mo???

No wonder! Ampatuan's are children of Satan!!!!!!! Wala siyang inisip kundi ang kanyang sariling interes!!!!! Hindi na siya naawa sa mga inosente!! May puso pa kaya ang taong ito? Mas mabuti pa ang saging may puso.......

Sa ipinakita ni pangulong arroyo......where is the justice jan? pagchur anak ui!!!!!!!!!

justice for the family of the those who are suffering......!!!!wakeup pangulo..

ilibing n ng buhay ang mga yan..salut sila sa lipunan..isali nyo na rin pangulo nyo..

kaylangan pa bang gumunaw ang mundo para mawala ang mga salot na politiko????? wala na ba silang ibang kayang gawin kundi pumatay??? Natutulog ba ang pamahalaan??? Bakit puro nalang salita wala namang kabutihang nagawa??

ahay.....damo pa sang mas importante dah! kadlawan lang mo ni ampatuan.....

maayo pa si ampatuan sikat.... ana man jud na para ma sikat... diin ka pa masikat kay diba sa paghimo ug dautan....try it....the world will be against you... ang mas mabuti pa manahimik nalang tayo..... though it is all our concern but what could we do...just until commenting? Mabubuhay ba yong mga minassaccre? makukulong yong may sala?... anu? diba hanggang salita lang tayo? sana kong ang bunganga natin ay may silda ciguro matagal ng nakulong yong may sala, pero wala. so better shut up..... period.

hustisya sa pamilya na namatayan!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Analyze correctly and think wisely!! ..... don't ignore the obvious... We need to use our brain logically, so that we may not become fool in looking the situation in Maguindanao. The evidences are valid and concrete... I could not find any concrete reason to excuse the Ampatuan's on that bloody massacre... Justice must be given to the grieving families of victims.. In connection to that, we need to critically see how the government impose the law to those who are responsible of the crime to avoid BIAS and decadence. I want to challenge the government to grow avid for the truth wherever it may be found and regardless of who said it. If the truth will not be achieve due to the process of careful investigation, then by the use of common sense I would say that they go against the sincere quest for the truth. If that will happened it simply show that our government is weak and paralyze....

You have a point Agaw Pot2. agree ako sayo. Bongga ka Pot.

Galinga Pot2 wui..

Galing jud pagtsut ui.....ampon raka

Galing magdrama ni Andal. Pang Oscar ang dating! sarap durugin at gawing fishball...Abaw linti!

DLRDIc mzslxhevtpqc, [url=http://llqvaixjfdpi.com/]llqvaixjfdpi[/url], [link=http://hhfxelkiyzbc.com/]hhfxelkiyzbc[/link], http://ucnywryirbpx.com/

PINKY IS RIGHT, KAMAONG BAKAL ANG GAGAMITIN SA MGA MAGAGALING NA PILIPINO DAHIL HINDI KAYA NANG DEMOKRASYA AT DAPAT TALAGA DICTATORSHIP ANG ATING BANSA KAGAYA NI MARCOS MAS GUSTO KO PA WALANG SINASANTO PATAYIN KAAGAD. MAGANDA IYON. WALANG HUMAN RIGHTS ANG DAPAT DIN KASI NAMIMIHASA ANG MGA GAGONG ULOL SA PILIPINAS. KE MAY EDUCATION AT WALA ANG FILIPINO IISA LANG ANG KAGAGAWAN NANG CRIMINAL SA POLITICS AND NON POLITICS. HINDI BA MGA KABABAYANNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!
SASALITA LANG TAYO PERO GUMAGAWA RIN.

Blogroll links aint that great :P but i am not the admin

This incident not only erases all doubts about the Philippines being the most dangerous country for journalists in the world, outside of Iraq, it could very well place the country on the map as a candidate for a failed democracy.

Running for office and voting are as much exercises of free will and expression as covering and reporting the news.
Best regards, Alex CEO of youtube downloader

The Ampatuan massacre, which the military has confirmed was perpetrated by Shariff Aguak Mayor Andal Ampatuan Jr. and police Senior Inspector Dicay, goes beyond the issue of freedom of the press and of expression and strikes at the very foundations of democracy.
latest songs, microsoft iscsi initiator

On the other hand it was a mistake for the Philippines to have not ratified the Rome Statute because the Ampatuan Massacre is definitely covered under the International Criminal Court. Best regards, Katya, CEO of sonic dvd burner, iscsi storage devices

The depth and quality of this post is really awesome. It is very knowledgeable information that could be very much helpful in IT as well as e-business industry. TurboTax free

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Veronica Uy published on November 24, 2009 2:22 AM.

Guess who's running against Bistek? was the previous entry in this blog.

Government must own up to climate of impunity is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.