Quantcast Assessing potential change in Burma - Living Abroad

Assessing potential change in Burma

| 124 Comments | No TrackBacks

By Ko Ko Thett



Editor's note: Ko Ko Thett is a Burma analyst based in Helsinki. This article was initially available at http://www.irrawaddy.org/opinion_story.php?art_id=17863.

 

 

HELSINKI, Finland--For Burma politicians, policy advocates, activists, watchers, sympathizers, scholars, do-gooders, and donors, frustration is a fact of life since potential for change into a democratic society has eluded everyone for more than 20 years.

 

Mass movements and revolutions, informed and inspired by the 1988 overthrow of the Burma Socialist Program Party, have made no headway since 1988. While each failed mass movement has had tragic human costs to the lives of individuals involved in it, the regime's weathering of each storm seems to have prepared them better for the next.

 

The new Burmese capital of Naypyidaw is now conveniently located at least 300 kilometers from each of the most populous cities, Rangoon in the South and Mandalay in the North, so people power cannot come near the government's seat of power.

 

The country's economy in real terms has worsened for the bottom 50 million, and the increased polarization of wealth offers little hope for those who argue "economy precedes politics."

 

The hardship for the people was so great even the sangha, who are supposed to be above the mundane world, came out en masse in late 2007, in what would be known as the Saffron Revolution.

 

The recent series of sit-ins for higher wages by Rangoon garment industry workers, most of whom are ladies carrying for extensive families, is just another indication of the dire straits of the common people. In Burma, one employed person may be supporting five unemployed persons--social protection by the state is non-existent save a measly pension scheme for veterans and former government employees.

 

Whereas the Burmese regime has made the best of its geopolitics and regionalization vis-à-vis the Asean countries, China and India, globalization and all its purported glories have passed over the country. If anything the global thirst for energy and the global security paranoia have favored the Burmese generals. As such, other factors indicative of democracy, such as the emergence of an enlightened middle class, the existence of a strong and independent civil society, the rescue of the country by a disillusioned political leadership within the government remain far-fetched.

 

The staunch opposition led by Aung San Suu Kyi has been the "voice of hope" for the politically minded section of the society and their Western supporters, but they have not shaken the regime since government functionaries at large remain unaffected. It can be argued that the "unaffectedness" has been caused by the regime's systematic persecution that is designed to isolate charismatic dissidents from the people. Inevitably, the Burmese opposition, as well as their Western supporters, are handy scapegoats that the regime can blame for its own failures.

 

The entrenched and institutionalized conflict between the ethnic autonomy groups and the central regime has also served as a way for the Burmese military to justify its militarist expansionist policies. Even natural and man-made calamities of great magnitude, such as Cyclone Nargis and the famine in Chin State, which would have huge potential for change in other societies appear to have only hardened the regime's callousness toward the suffering of the people.

 

Make no mistake. The regime's initiative, the "Road Map to Democracy," does not offer a glimmer of hope. All institutions advocated by the author Robert Dahl as vital for any large-scale democracy: elected officials, free fair and frequent elections, freedom of expressions, alternative sources of information, associational autonomy, inclusive citizenship, are nowhere to be found on the Road Map, except for "elected officials" who are widely anticipated to be elected in a controlled, regime-friendly parliament. In addition, the threat of another military coup always lurks beneath the current Constitution. Another putsch means going back to the late 1980s, if not the early 1960s.

 

Yet no matter how well prepared the regime is, the 2010 elections, and all the elections thereafter, will not be foolproof. Inasmuch as the looming elections have cornered the opposition into a "double bind," the regime is also acutely aware that it is walking a tight rope holding a balancing pole they call the 2008 Constitution. The regime has to balance between two inherently contradictory quests: one for national and international legitimacy and the other for the top generals' need to remain as sole arbitrators of state power, which is essential for them to be able to avoid the fate of fallen dictators.

 

If the elections are free, fair, and inclusive, as the international community insists, the regime risks losing a bigger-than-expected slide of their power--even within the current constitutional context. If the elections are not free and fair, the regime will be met with continued international condemnation and local resistance, a continuation of the status quo.

 

It would not be surprising if the generals in Naypyidaw are as apprehensive about the 2010 elections as the opposition itself. Perhaps, the opposition should treat the 2010 elections as an opportunity for change, including much desired constitutional change.

If history is any guide, elections all over the world have undermined colonial and authoritarian systems, rather than entrenched them. Elections, even defined and sponsored by repressive regimes for their own sake, usually backfire since they tend to arouse political debate, increase political awareness, and promote people's participation in politics.

 

 

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

No TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://blogs.inquirer.net/cgi/mt/mt-tb.cgi/11011

124 Comments

I believe Burma is in a way better situation now than it was a few years ago. I still remember how badly it was depicted in the movie Rambo 4. According to me, the only reason keeping that country from developing quickly is the geographical lacation and the intense corruption among the officials.
Regards,
demotivational posters

Burma is one of the more up and coming travel destinations. Because of their low accident rates many people travel there without travel insurance. This gives the island something else to offer besides it's beaches and tourist activities. Being to offer several different options to your customers will provide extra bang for their buck.

I genuinely liked reading through your post!. Quality material. I might advise you to come up with blogposts even more often. By doing this, having this kind of a worthy website I think you will probably rank higher in the paper writing

You don't know how much I love it too. What a big fun when you can celebrate it with friends. Bristol Airport Car Parking

The Burma junta is a totalitarian as it always was and the coming elections are likely to be a sham. It's a pity Aung Sung Su Kyi's freedoms are still being curtailed. Hilton Nairobi

"Elections, even defined and sponsored by repressive regimes for their own sake, usually backfire since they tend to arouse political debate, increase political awareness, and promote people's participation in politics."

too true

-brad
glass test tubes

Burma is really a nice place and its a developing country hence in coming years the economy of Burma would definitely improve.

Maggi James,Indian Recipes Community Center

http://besterectionpills.net/

Best Erection Pills, Free Erection Pills, Erection Pills Review

Natural Viagra Substitutes and ED Remedies popularity has grown significantly. Billions of

people around the globe use natural remedies now to cure ED related problems. We review them

and find best erection pills.

Burma is a resource-rich country that suffers from government controls and abject rural poverty. A great deal of economic activity in Burma is unrecorded. Some analysts believe the informal economy is larger than the formal economy.
baby girls clothes

Love, game, astrology and fortune become one in here. One stop fun for everyone. glasgow property

Burma's onshore energy supplies of crude oil and natural gas are declining rapidly.

Club Penguin Secrets

Burma needs to take care of it's people first and just perhaps this time the elections will bring positive change. Muscle Cars

A free and fair election will be held this year in keeping with the country’s new 2008 constitution.

Poptropica Cheats

''Perhaps, the opposition should treat the 2010 elections as an opportunity for change, including much desired constitutional change. '' - Indeed. They will see no change if the approach to the elections remains the same and all it will cause is more political unrest, mostly from the population.
watch movies online

It's indeed a pity Aung Sung Su Kyi's freedoms are still being curtailed.

Test Equipment

The staunch opposition led by Aung San Suu Kyi has been the "voice of hope" for the politically minded section of the society and their Western supporters, but they have not shaken the regime since government functionaries at large remain unaffected. It can be argued that the "unaffectedness" has been caused by the regime's systematic persecution that is designed to isolate charismatic dissidents from the people. Inevitably, the Burmese opposition, as well as their Western supporters, are handy scapegoats that the regime can blame for its own failures.

The entrenched and institutionalized conflict between the ethnic autonomy groups and the central regime has also served as a way for the Burmese military to justify its militarist expansionist policies. Even natural and man-made calamities of great magnitude, such as Cyclone Nargis and the famine in Chin State, which would have huge potential for change in other societies appear to have only hardened the regime's callousness toward the suffering of the people.

Make no mistake. The regime's initiative, the "Road Map to Democracy," does not offer a glimmer of hope. All institutions advocated by the author Robert Dahl as vital for any large-scale democracy: elected officials, free fair and frequent elections, freedom of expressions, alternative sources of information, associational autonomy, Buy Facebook Fans,inclusive citizenship, are nowhere to be found on the Road Map, except for "elected officials" who are widely anticipated to be elected in a controlled, regime-friendly parliament. In addition, the threat of another military coup always lurks beneath the current Constitution. Another putsch means going back to the late 1980s, if not the early 1960s.

The political situation in Burma remains unsettled and tensions could resurface as preparations for the elections due in November 2010 gather momentum.

Australia signage and
Signs Sydney

Let's hope the elections are successful. The poor people of Burma need a strong government.

Bill Wolforth - refinance mortgage
specialist

I hope that their elections give them a strong government that will help them so they can have good lives.
Amber Breaux @ Affordable Health Insurance

This is a really interesting article. Burma is always having problems and hopefully they can get it resolved.

Thanks Danielle Henderson
SEO

Aung San Suu Kyi has battled with the government for years now. Having lived under house arrest for most of the last several years, the lasy has still had the courage and belief to stand by her principles. I do admire her for that. But I think its time the international community needs to work towards Burmese cause. Hindi Movies

I think she's amazing. The character is so alive. She will nominated for oscar I think. cheap auto insurance

My Dear

Great job.
Ofcourse, what a great site and informative posts.
But I can't uderstand how to add your site in my rss reader. Can you Help me please?
Anyhow keep up the good work.

Yours Sincerely

http://herbalviagrainfo.com/

It's all about having a government that puts the people first. If the people have no power, they have no hope.
Homeowner Loans

Hopefully we will see Burma get back on its feet in the future. I just hate to see people suffering and no one is trying to help them.

Thanks Sara Powell
Alternative Cancer Clinics

This is a very exhilirating article. Burma is always has problems and I really do hope that they can get them resolved soon and keep it that way.

Thanks Son Best
Mobile Phone Recycling.

Google Buzz has just been popular recently here. I like the features. But it is a bit too formal for me. Maybe Google doesn't target those at their early 20s. funeral plan

Wow! Thank you! I always wanted to write in my site something like that. Can I take part of your post to my blog?
Custom sticker printing

I'm happy I found this blog, I couldnt discover any info on this subject matter prior to. I also run a site and if you want to ever serious in a little bit of guest writing for me if possible feel free to let me know, i\'m always look for people to check out my site. Please stop by and leave a comment sometime!!!
cheap st. louis rams tickets | cheap san francisco 49ers tickets

I do hope that the elections went as clean as possible. Its sad to see a country be so devastated by so many problems.
Dale Roller Versicherung

Respects is all we need to give if you want the society respected you. This is the rules in every place we live in. online colleges

I hope that their elections give them a strong government that will help them so they can have good lives.

car insurance reviews

I believe Burma is in a way better situation now than it was a few years ago. I still remember how badly it was depicted in the movie Rambo 4. According to me, the only reason keeping that country from developing quickly is the geographical lacation and the intense corruption among the officials.
Regards,
Buy Facebook Fans

Burmese government should end an escalating campaign of repression, release political prisoners, and begin a dialogue with opposition groups and start respecting human rights. Irena from personal loans

Manyclassic films as well notable filmmakers came from the country. Namely Ingmar Bergman, Victor Sjostrom and many others. Their influence is practical in these days. free business listing

GPS use trhe android system in it. It makes the gpd design more compact and slim. You can put that in your car or even bring it everywhere you need. free business listing

They have rights too. We must respect that. I know its hard to see and to understand why and what make them have to leave their country and make a decision to stay in other country as a immigrant. sentricon

IN my country we have a big area for all the immigrant. Our government serve that place for them. Its like a district. And you know what? This district have a good economy than in our district. Funny right? t-shirt printing

I like obama to become our president. This is the first time I loke our country leader. He have a good charisma and know what to do. He is smart and always avoid war. This is why I like him. Dish Network Deals

Many war happen and many people were killed in that war. It means that many young people will become a soldier to protect their country. This is not good. test de parenté

Every photographer always try the best to make a good quality photo. This will show you how big the talent that they have. In my country there a good photographer. All the people that live in a major city must be heard or know his name. san francisco car accident attorney

This game called monster vs alien, i think thats right. I remember i watch the movie several years ago. Now they re making a game version. This is cool. I will download this game. If its good i will buy the full version of this. afdx

They have only official photo in this site. Many photo come from many different country. You can see a lot of different culture in all that picture. Dissertation Editing Services

I really like the photo scene. the sky is very beautiful and bright blue. I want to know where he took the photo it. he should write about it in uploading this photo. Sälja guld

Even if you want to wark as a bookshop keeper you meed to make a cv. This is a must. First condition for every job that you want to have. Good cv mean you have a good skill as long as you can prove what you are write in your cv. chiropractor lawrenceville

This is a good place. You have a lake near your place> wow, there is nothing like this in my country. You must be love this place and never get bored live here. debt consolidation

A good mags mean that you can make the reader enjoy the content of yopur mags. This mean that you need to make a research to find out what make people interest so they want to buy your mags. Check My Credit Now

I think that the Burma situation is very similar to the struggles in Nepal. I just hope that it turns out much better.

Mike the term life insurance guy

If you jion in every foundation that in your country you should write that in your cv too. Just make sure you write everything that important and the good thing that you do in your life. That is a good value too.
Industry Magazines

They have a good education system. Sometimes the teacher ask their students to have a good education by do a recreation. The teacher teach bout that we must take care our nature. diet plans

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Veronica Uy published on February 23, 2010 7:08 AM.

Dad writes to daughter about Valentine's was the previous entry in this blog.

What links Scots and Filipinos? is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.