Quantcast The scam that rattled high society - Money Smarts

The scam that rattled high society

| 36 Comments | 1 TrackBack
High Society (Photo credit: AFP) I missed seeing this article in the Philippine Daily Inquirer when it came out in end-March, but I think it’s worthy enough to be shared again in MoneySmarts, just in case you guys missed reading it too. Say it with me. “If it’s too good to be true…” Enjoy reading! (For those who want to blog about this or forward to friends, please link back to MoneySmarts or the page where the article was published. Stealing content is a crime against your own personal integrity. It's not worth it ☺) ~~~~~~~****~~~~~~~ The scam that rattled high society By Marge C. Enriquez Philippine Daily Inquirer First Posted 02:08:00 03/30/2008 MANILA, Philippines - If it’s too good to be true, then it’s not true,” Carrie (not her real name), a businesswoman, says, breaking into nervous laughter. She is referring to the illusion of easy returns from risky speculative investments. In July 2007, news broke of a scandal involving the Singaporean boss of a foreign exchange trading firm who was suspected of running away with some US$250 million of investors’ funds. The people who invested were the powerful, the rich and the beautiful. Every time the Performance Investment Products Corporation (PIPC) scam is brought up, Samantha (not her real name), also a businesswoman, prefers to wax philosophical: “I made so much money. I was devastated but it took some time to heal. We have to go on with our lives.” In 1998, Michael “Mike” Liew, the Singaporean owner, established PIPC as an online foreign exchange trading firm in the Philippines. Carrie was invited by a friend to an introductory lecture of the PIPC by Liew at Hotel Intercontinental. People were asked to put in a minimum of US$40,000 in a trading scheme staking on gains or losses in pairs of currencies. The PIPC traders did business on these monies. Carrie was attracted by the guaranteed return of 10-15 percent every maturity period of eight weeks, or an average annual return of 12 percent a year. “With $40,000 and a 12-percent return after eight weeks, you could earn $5,000,” says Carrie. Warning Before Carrie could invest, a banker-friend warned her it could be a scam. The banker found it anomalous that an investor would dispatch the money to Hong Kong and would not get a deposit slip in the investor’s name. “Let’s say you remitted through Citibank which, in turn, remitted to ABN-Amro in Hong Kong,” Carrie says. “You get a confirmation from PIPC, not from ABN-Amro. It’s a laminated plastic receipt stating you are an investor of PIPC of $40,000, plus your remittance and the account number.” After the Intercon presentation, the banker, now convinced of the scheme, suggested they try a joint account, starting with $20,000 each. “We began making good money and would share it,” Carrie says. “She said, ‘Let’s go on separate ways because our dividend is nice. We don’t lose anything because every eight weeks, we get back our money.’ PIPC sends a notice saying that your deposit is maturing on this day. If you don’t want to roll it, just advise the office and you will get your money in your bank account. We tried it. Sure enough, we recovered our money. As the years went buy, she put more and more.” Somebody went to Singapore to scrutinize PIPC’s operations. He reported that it was listed in the stock exchange and gave his nod to invest. The circle of investors felt more secure about his endorsement so that they increased their deposits. When Carrie went to Shanghai, she checked out PIPC’s office and was also impressed that it was in a swank building that had Louis Vuitton and Gucci as tenants. Word got around in high society. In the late ’90s, Samantha approached a PIPC trader and expressed her interest in the scheme. Carrie and Samantha felt they were in good hands since they had known most of the PIPC employees for a long time, and many of them came from respectable families. Dividends Carrie also saw Liew, who was always conservatively dressed in a suit and wearing a Rolex or a Patek Philippe. He motivated his employees to work hard so that PIPC would be another Merrill Lynch. The firm’s transactions were very organized. “Let’s say PIPC traded on March 1 and made $400 for you, minus the commission and management fees, your net was $260,” Carrie says. “They gave each investor one trading sheet per week. It would be summarized every two weeks so that you could see the progress of the trade. PIPC deposits your interest to your bank account. You don’t touch the money. The bank will tell you there’s a deposit of $800 or $1,000 in your dollar account. The sheet informs you of the next maturity date. “Every eight weeks PIPC sends the trading sheet. They e-mail or mail a sheet, how much you’ve made during the eight-week period. It states your next maturity date. If you don’t want to roll it over, advise the office two weeks before. If you want your capital of $40,000 back, tell the office. They will remit it to your bank account. Even if you don’t roll it, you will get your interest,” says Carrie. “I never saw the dividends dwindling. They were just inconsistent. PIPC made us believe that our shares depended on the trade. I even got a zero in an eight-week period in October 2006. Before that I got a $2,200 dividend. At the end of 12 months, I still got 12.5 percent annual return.” Perks PIPC knew how to win its investors. On the first year, they were given a $50 bonus, and were gifted with luxury items such as Hermés scarves and free foreign magazine subscriptions. The first Christmas party was at the Peninsula Hotel ballroom, attended by the high and the mighty. “We were in good company,” exclaims Samantha. In the next three years, the Christmas parties were held in five-star ballrooms. When the big parties stopped, PIPC sent cards to the investors saying that in lieu of a party, the money would be given to charity. The recipient even sent thank-you cards to the investors, making them feel that part of their money was used for noble causes. In another year, the Philippine General Hospital gave Liew a plaque for his generosity in the renovation of its obstetrics and gynecology wing. He dedicated the project to family members who had died in the tsunami in Thailand. Carrie was impressed with the firm’s growth. PIPC started with a simple office at the Antel building until operations expanded to two floors. Then it moved to the Citibank Tower, where it even had a plush lounge. Investors could enjoy free coffee, pastries, wines and canapés. It had offices in Singapore, Japan, India and China and, eventually, Cebu. “You felt safe because our capital was guaranteed,” says Carrie. They were made to believe that an investor not earning anything was the worst-case scenario. When the business evolved with a second money scheme, the money game became precarious. “In Plan A, you got 60 percent while the company got 40 percent. If a trader made $1,000 for you in the eight-week period, your net interest would be $600, while $400 went to the office. Your $40,000 was still intact. “With Plan B, you got 80 percent while the organization got 20 percent. But the risk was that the capital was no longer guaranteed. If the trader lost, you shared in his losses. At the end of an eight-week period, you could have $39,000 instead of your $40,000 because your trader lost $1,000. But you could still recover in the next period. Many took Plan B,” says Carrie. Addicting Many investors opened several accounts so that they would get more dividends in shorter intervals. There was talk that one of the biggest investors was a low-key Chinese businessman who put in $5 million. While well-meaning friends, financial experts and businessmen cautioned Samantha of fraudulent money schemes, the immediate gratification was addicting. Lured by temptation, she kept holding off the withdrawal of her accounts. The friendly service of PIPC and Liew’s charisma won people over. “The relationship was based on trust. For nine years, the company showed good performance with the interests that it was giving you. You would not have one iota of doubt about the company,” says Carrie. Massage parlor On July 17, 2007, Carrie’s account executive informed her that Liew was missing. At first, she thought it was irrelevant. The AE explained that money was not coming in for the company to distribute among the investors and to pay the salaries of its employees. Liew’s mother supposedly put him on a missing persons’ list. Finally, Liew reportedly called his mother after two weeks and said she should go to the United States. Newspaper reports would eventually state that Liew had fled with the money. The bank accounts that held the investments of Carrie, Samantha and thousands of others had been cleared out. PIPC’s Singapore office pointed out that the missing funds had been kept in three banks and that Liew had closed an account in Hong Kong. Publications quoted the Philippine Securities and Exchange Commission as saying that PIPC was registered with controllers, but it was not a legitimate foreign exchange trading firm. The High Court of Hong Kong hired Ferrier Hodgson, a company specializing in financial investigations and frauds, forensic accounting and IT and business assessment, as provisional liquidator of PIPC. Initial findings revealed that PIPC lacked accounting books and records. Control was in the hands of a few and that only Liew knew how the funds flowed. He also manipulated the bank accounts of the investors’ funds. More shocking was that trading had stopped in 2004, yet new investors were still coming in. Ferrier Hodgson investigated the three banks in Hong Kong where deposits had been made. The report also revealed that the PIPC office in Singapore Land Tower had not been used for a month, yet there were arrangements for calls and mails. However, calls were forwarded to a discontinued number and the mail address was a massage parlor. Devastated and outraged, the Philippine investors held meetings. Samantha had already pulled out some of her money before Liew’s escape. She was about to deposit again, but could not contact her AE. Although she was grateful that she had been spared huge losses, she was still confounded. The meetings merely distressed her more. Many investors wanted to get even. “They had their own way of dealing with the scandal. I just forgot about it. That’s money gone forever,” sighs Samantha. Broken lives “The real character of people came out,” says Carrie. “Some sued the account executives and officers even if they were good friends or relatives. But they had signed a contract stating that the AE was not culpable. We invested on our own volition. How could I blame Mike [Liew] or the AE?” Couples split, blaming each other for their financial mess. A mother had a son who was an AE. After putting in money and gaining from it, she placed more. Then she died. During the meeting for the inheritance, the children were left with very little assets. She had put all her money in PIPC. A friend consolidated her stocks, sold them and put the money in PIPC a month before it fell. She did not even get a single interest. That money was meant to be a down payment for her son’s apartment in New York to start him off after graduation. Many lost face (aside from their jobs or retirement money) for referring friends to or brokering an account with PIPC; their friends never forgave them. On the other hand, there were those who took the fiasco positively. Carrie says: “It was a wake-up call for many. Maybe God was telling us to stop being materialistic and to look into our real values. If you have so much, greed comes in... The moment I let go, I became peaceful.”

1 TrackBack

TrackBack URL: http://blogs.inquirer.net/cgi/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1325

piano rapidshare... Hello ;) Thanks heaps for this indeed!... if anyone else has anything, it would be much appreciated. Great website Super Piano Links http://www.en.Grand-Pianos.org Enjoy!...----- PING: TITLE: gmarris URL: http://www.financial.newinformationarticles.com DATE: 12/01/2009 06:31:36 AM IP: 74.86.148.194 gmarris... ...----- PING: TITLE: Why Scams Happen and Why They Happen Again and Again » The Warrior Lawyer | Philippine Lawyer URL: http://thewarriorlawyer.com/2009/02/01/why-scams-happen-and-why-they-happen-again-and-again/ DATE: 02/01/2009 09:59:11 PM IP: 72.34.43.63 [...] the Multitel pyramid swindle ? And just a little over a year ago, the Performance Investment Products Corporation (PIPC) scam, a Ponzi set-up masquerading as a foreign exchange firm which victimized members of [...]----- -------- Read More

36 Comments

If somebody tells me he will give me 6% a month, the first thing I will ask is what investment will give that high return consistently? I know some deals can give higher returns but the question is consistency. You don’t always get great deals. You will lose money on some bad deals so the average return will be lower. Only a Ponzi scheme can give very high return consistently until it collapses.

wow! nine years!

Never put all your eggs in one basket. Currency trading is more volatile than stocks. Add to that that your money is immediately leveraged.

Greed is therapeutic.

I invested in PIPC and lost more than half a million pesos. The investors had meetings before but until now, there is now word whether we can receive a refund.

Interestingly, before PIPC collapsed I was also invited to join the Royal Manchester trading program. Fortunately for me, I declined. Otherwise I would have lost a lot of money to these 2 scams.

There are more info about PIPC and the Manchester scam here by the way.

PIPC

Royal Manchester

dear sir/madam,

if you want to barrow money from me, just give me 5% a month call me at my cell number, i am very rich...

091753531430 I am fort Ilocandia resort casino treasury head, i drive a fortuner ahh 143 and live in the resort...

correct cell number 09175353143

there is a Chinese adage that states that the chinese words of "greed" and "poverty" shares the same configuration. This PIPC episode, as are other scams in the past, is conclusive proof of the truth of this wise adage. Greed indeeds leads to poverty!

Classic:

Hangga't me naloloko, me manloloko.


hahahaha

This just shows how gullible Filipinos are. We allow people to take advantage of us and we bury our heads in the sand if and when we see something wrong. It took 20 years for us to realize that Marcos was looting the Philippines. After 300 cases Imelda Marcos, et al are still scott free going around the country as if she has not committed anything. Notwithstanding his clear incompetence, a lot of Filipinos voted for Erap. It took 3 years for us to realize that Erap was just like Marcos - a crook. Worse, its taking us 8 years to realize that GMA and Mike Arroyo are crooks as well. So its no surprise that we allow crooks in our country and to steal from us. We have a history of gullibility. The fact that those who invested in this scam were the elite, it just shows that the uneducted is not the only one who is gullible. This is probably a good time to learn from our mistakes and start putting these crooks in jail.

Find that guy Michael “Mike” Liew and make him our finance minister.

Milliken, Bear Stearns also sold junk paper or toxic instruments not to people but to Citigroup, UBS, Merrill Lynch and many other financial institutions. The credit rating agencies, S&P, Moodys and Fitch all gave these toxic instruments Triple A ratings.

What happened ?????

The intellectual capacity and weight at these financial institutions (PHD's and MBA's) would sink the Philippines.

okay lang. That is why the Jews are the best businessmen in the world. They do not trust anyone when it comes to business. If you want to succeed without blaming others, you should be hands on in your business. Yun lang yon.

yes..the poor bites the bait to put the crook to the top; the rich bites the bait to make the crook richer. all for the hope of hope; all for the hope of becoming richer.

Salve, thank you for posting this article to warn new investor investing in this kind of trade.

The aftermath of the fiasco will be much worst as some lossers will tend to get back their money by putting the same scheme, promising high interset rates - victimizing the poor with hard earned savings like the OFW.

Mike Milken aka the junk bond king was a financial genius and the biggest scammer of all time. He created and manipulated the $200 billion junk bond market by manipulating various financial institutions to execute complex financial crimes. He probably pocketed $3 billion before he was convicted in 1990. He paid a fine of $600 M and served 2 yrs. in prison. He’s now a free man and still very rich.

His real-life story was documented in the book “Den of Thieves” by James Stewart. The irony and tragedy of Mike Milken was he would have been very successful and very rich even without resorting to criminal activities. A summa cum laude graduate of Berkeley and Wharton, he was hailed as a financial innovator by no less than Alan Greenspan. Greed got the better of him.

tarantrader, thanks for the tip. i dare say, though, too many Filipinos get into these scams because in the first place, we don't know what baskets we can choose from.

argentius, greed is therapeutic? what in the world does that mean??

i-was-scammed, sorry to hear that you were one of the victims. do the victims really expect to get back their money? how would you rate the government's response on this scam?

vincent tiong, what racket are you running??

joengaw, i just wish the greedy one is the person who eventually gets mired in poverty. unfortunately, that's far from true :-(

habaratbu, masakit man isipin, pero tama ka sa sinabi mong yan.

Sam, there are gullible people everywhere in the world. There are many "Marcoses" and "Imelda Marcoses" (maybe except the shoe fetish) and GMAs in the world. We don't have the monopoly in gullibility, unfortunately. i don't know if that makes anyone feel better.

hvrds, your comment is witty and made me smile. but seriously, i would rather have a less brilliant finance minister if it means having one with integrity. i'm sure you would too, right?

k rene, very well said. i hope that everyone who reads moneysmarts will not tire of me saying we don't strive to be wealthy for money's sake alone. otherwise, we will step on anything and everything -- and go into crooked deals like liew -- just to be wealthy.

boy, you're welcome. dear heavens, i hope your prediction doesn't come true but the philippines seems to be murphy's favorite. :-( anything that can go wrong goes wrong in the PI. Sigh.

Pinoy Investor, greed appears to be the word of the year and "moderate greed" a particularly fitting phrase for Filipinos. For Mike Millken, the word is "sayang". I wonder why there is no single word translation for that in English.

You think he would give up all that wealth for a clean name?

GOOD FOR YOU GREEDY IDIOTS.

salve,
Milken spends a lot of money in philanthropy to get a good image. But he may not even believe he had done anything wrong. Some people think he was a victim. They say securities violations were rampant in Wall Street and the prosecutors singled out Milken and invented new interpretations of the law to criminalize his violations because he became too powerful and was a threat to corporate America. His annual conferences were dubbed as the Predator’s Ball. It was a pilgrimage of corporate raiders in the US. Milken was their spiritual leader and icon.

Those who got in early benefited from this. But people will never learn as long as there is easy money to be made. The recent fiasco with the some of the Legacy companies (not the banks because it is protected by PDIC) particularly their pre-need products where offers of double your money in 1 year should be already be a red flag and has scam written all over it.

2004 allows source non thus atlantic earth scheme [url=http://www.ccrc.sr.unh.edu]thermohaline least causes order[/url] http://www.caribic-atmospheric.com

broader found human vectors dioxide working product positive

Could you help me. It is not enough to do good; one must do it the right way. Help me! Looking for sites on: Mexican source pharmacy. I found only this - http://www.thevalleyschool.in/Members/MexicanPharmacy/mexican-pharmacy-online-no-rx. Mexican pharmacy, mueller, christina very. When we scammed off the situation, it was not on symptoms we reported through the antioxidant, mexican pharmacy. With respect :o, Gavin from Indonesia.

Check pills prices, save your dollars! Fast, Discreet shipping worldwide. High anonymity! Buy Viagra Online
http://www.thegeenadavisinstitute.org/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=12900 Buy Viagra Online i D R O Q 7 0 8 3 4 Great Discounts. Free Fedex shipping. Professional Customer Service! http://board.teamdistort.com/index.php?action=profile;u=34226 Cialis I F z 4 Q 4 6 9 0 7 Don't lose your time! Welcome to our online pharmacy! http://www.thegeenadavisinstitute.org/forum/index.php?action=profile;u=12885 Buy Levitra Online h l R m k 1 2 5 3 0 We are in business for years, so shoping is 100% safe! http://fr.smash-online.com/forum/member.php?u=10705 Buy Propecia A a 0 1 3 3 9 4 2 5 Discreet Packing. Free Shipping, Free Consultation. http://board.teamdistort.com/index.php?action=profile;u=34223 Acomplia R d 1 g Z 3 1 0 4 2 We provide only HIGH QUALITY pills.
NO prescription needed, WORLDWIDE shipping. Great Discounts. Free Fedex shipping. Professional Customer Service! Viagra
http://www.freecodesource.com/community/forums/showthread.php?p=53370 Buy Viagra Online S F 0 a w 9 5 7 6 0 Save your time - buy pills right now! http://board.teamdistort.com/index.php?topic=95727.0 Buy Cialis 6 J 4 C D 8 9 3 0 6 Fast, Discreet shipping worldwide. Special offers! http://swimmablenyc.info/forum/index.php?topic=112541.0 Levitra Online t L b k m 2 1 4 6 7 We provide only HIGH QUALITY pills. http://board.teamdistort.com/index.php?topic=96118.0 Buy Propecia On Line C r k l Y 7 2 8 4 5 FDA Approved. Brand and generic drugs. No Prescription required. http://board.teamdistort.com/index.php?topic=95710.0 Buy Acomplia On Line U c T n V 8 0 7 6 3 Save your money and time, choose only the best!
http://www.playlist.com/blog/entry/12492741891 buy Viagra http://www.playlist.com/blog/entry/12492728323 buy viagra in australia
http://www.playlist.com/blog/entry/12492704259 buy viagra in canada http://www.playlist.com/blog/entry/12492680195 buy viagra low cost http://www.playlist.com/blog/entry/12492602371 buy viagra
http://0-buying.cheaprxshop.com/map.html 1 4 dose propecia. http://buyonlinerx.t35.com propecia chemical http://cost-low.cheaprxshop.com/map.html cost of propecia. persistent propecia effects http://propecia-that.cheaprxshop.com/map.html propecia the prostitute. propecia and receding hairline http://propecia-and.cheaprxshop.com/map.htm |propecia and transsexual. propecia dont take http://propecia-liver.cheaprxshop.com/map.html propecia long term. propecia blinddate parody http://internet-pharma.cheaprxshop.com/map.html is buying propecia online legal. proscar instead of propecia
http://0-buying.cheaprxshop.com/index.html 1 4 dose propecia. propecia chemical http://cost-low.cheaprxshop.com/index.html cost of propecia. persistent propecia effects cost of propecia. persistent propecia effects
http://propecia-that.cheaprxshop.com/index.html propecia the prostitute. propecia and receding hairline propecia the prostitute. propecia and receding hairline http://propecia-and.cheaprxshop.com/index.html propecia and transsexual. propecia dont take propecia and transsexual. propecia dont take http://propecia-liver.cheaprxshop.com/index.html propecia long term. propecia blinddate parody propecia long term. propecia blinddate parody http://internet-pharma.cheaprxshop.com/index.html is buying propecia online legal. proscar instead of propecia is buying propecia online legal. proscar instead of propecia

Greed is therapeutic.
Best regards, Alex, CEO of youtube downloader

Publications quoted the Philippine Securities and Exchange Commission as saying that PIPC was registered with controllers, but it was not a legitimate foreign exchange trading firm.
Best regards, Katya, CEO of cd rw burner, red hat iscsi initiator

A sure 12% seems outstanding on a market like this. I heard about the market many years back and phrases such as forex or financial spread bet were nothing to me back then. I know you can risk it all and win big money but you could also lose everything you've got and many people advised I should work with surplus money only. On the other hand I would be thrilled to be earning a sure 12% on any market... life doesn't seem to be fair for the most of us.

Pages

Powered by Movable Type 5.01

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by published on April 18, 2008 8:41 AM.

Greedy Western Union outlet and the moneychanger was the previous entry in this blog.

Frugality Week: Filipinos throw away P23M daily due to rice wastage is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.