Quantcast

Teaching kids about needs and wants

01/06/09

Posted under family finance, kids and money

“How do you teach children the difference between wants and needs?” a viewer texted ABS-CBN’s Shoptalk yesterday after host Pia Hontiveros and I spent the better part of an hour talking about financial literacy for kids.

The studio lights felt warm on my face and the ticking clock made me mumble a couple of excuses for an answer. My daughter and best critic who was watching assured me I did good, but in the harsh reality of 24-hours-after, I am now mortified at how I missed the opportunity to dissect a very important personal finance dilemma for parents.

Forget teaching most adults about wants versus needs. Most of us are hopeless. But children? The spending habits we instill in a child will make more impact on his financial life than any investment he may make in his future. I can’t even begin to explain how critical it is for a child to have a clear grasp of this concept.

How? I search inward at my own parenting efforts. Have I been a good example? Have I taken the time to at least discuss the seeming lack of difference between a need and a want at the exact moment the wanna-have-it gremlins are making such a ruckus in his mind? That when he is an adult, he would be torn between bigger things than a Timezone caper or a drum set? That eventually, his decisions now will define him as a person later on?

In hindsight, here are the things that I think I should have told that viewer and that I aim to do more often in the future:

  1. Teach him to delay the purchase and take time to think together. An infant needs instant gratification. When he cries for a feeding or because he hates the feeling of a soiled diaper, or when he wants a cuddle, I believe parents should give it to him immediately. A child, on the other hand, has to start learning the survival skill of thinking first if his desires need to be instantly gratified or not. While foremost a money lesson, this will also later on develop in him the crucial values of sacrifice and giving way to a greater good. So, take time outs. One day or two days will make a huge difference in extracting him from the pressure of the spending situation and teaching him to think about whether something is a want or a need.
  2. Consider options and learn the art of being a thinking spender. A child is best taught when things are visual. List down possible options. With P5,000 given by relatives last Christmas, what are the things that he can buy? Allow him to visualize and compare prices. Let him think about what is more practical.
  3. Let him think about long-term goals. Would it be better to save the P5,000 and make it grow so he can buy something he really needs? Try to teach him about compound interest and see if he wants to grow the P5,000 by investing it in a time deposit or a mutual fund.
  4. Bring him to the grocery and show him how substituting works. Take advantage when the kids want to help with the grocery! At a certain age, they just want to leave that chore to mom. But while they still want to push the cart, incorporate a lesson on how substituting items can bring down the grocery bill. Come to think of it, there have been several times when the kids have saved me a couple of hundred pesos in the grocery.
  5. Give him rewards when he saves instead of spends. Double his savings or give him treats. Appreciate his efforts when he asks for an opportunity to earn money to “feed” his mobile phone instead of just asking for “load”. When they feel good about doing something, they stick with it longer.

Re-reading my list, I realize kids are not the ones who will benefit from it. Do you have any you want to add?

The other guests in the show were Pioneer Life senior vice-president Rolly Robles and Blue Cow chief operating officer Nanjo Berba. They talked about an interesting financial literacy course for children both companies have designed to create savers out of the younger generation.

Pioneer Life and Blue Cow have also developed a comic book called Private Iris that uses the Nancy Drew/Hardy Boys-type plots to teach young ones about saving and investing. Watch a video of an interview by INQUIRER.net multimedia specialist Erika Tapalla with writer Jaime Bautista.

I thought it was interesting that a financial services company is giving back to the community via education. It’s a good marketing move as well as this actually enlarges the market for life insurance and other financial services.





9 Feedbacks on "Teaching kids about needs and wants"



nina

Parents should be able to teach by example for it to be effective. What I notice is that in the family, kids grow up very much like their parents. If the parents have different personalities, kids grew up either like the mother or the father :) Though some people want to be different from their parents naman :)

Not always true but a frugal person most likely grew up with frugal parents/family while a spendthrift person most likely has either or both parents also spendthrift - and yes, I’m speaking from experience.



leela

i think pinaka-important is to be a good example. kahit pa turuan araw-araw, the child will not follow if he sees his parents squandering money.

happy new year!



paetechie

i am frugal, always on the lookout for cheap items without compromising quality…but my siblings are not…i don’t know why :(



businessman

It’s very important that children these days know the difference between the two. When they grow up they can be more responsible about their finances.



Katherine

When my daughter asks me to buy something she wants, I tell her that we have priorities right now like paying for the house mortgage, health insurance, saving for her college and saving for my retirement. I also tell her that we cannot spend all of my income on her wants since we have to save too. I sometimes show her what we have saved so far.

I am a single parent and I feel I owe it to her to teach her on finances. When we do the groceries together and she picks up an item, I ask her to compare prices and get the one with the lesser price. So, right now she knows how much is expensive and how much is reasonable.



sherwin

nice article again…
I remember when I just told my 7 yr ols daughter in the car last Christmas when She saw some ads for Barbie and other toys…

She said ” I want a Barbie Dad, buy me a Barbie po”

I asked her… Do you NEED that Barbie?

She replied, Hindi po.. gusto ko lang.

and there started the Needs Vs. Want education. At least now She knows the difference and can start applying it on her own.

She is also learning to set aside her baon… though She only started to have one when she topped the class… a deal that we made :)



Leo Ebreo

With ” rampant consumerism of contemporary society” it’s really hard to maintain parents influence over their children. Almost every second kids are bombarded by TV commercials promoting products and services endorse by TV and movie stars. Plus peer pressure while in school.

Here’s an excerpt from My Budget Planner 4 Kids by Tatiana Shevchuk’s -A ROCKEFELLER STORY.

Billionaire John D. Rockefeller Jr. taught his children to value money. He raised vegetables and raffbit so his children could work and earn money. According to son Nelson, “We got 25 cents a week, and to earn the rest of the money we were required:
. to keep personal daily account books
. give 10% of income to charity, and
. save 10% of their income.”

Interesting! You’d expect that these kids, raised in the lap of luxury, wouldn’t need to learn these things. Yet Rockefeller wanted his kids to understand and value money.

So, parents please teach your children while they’re in their formative years not only the value of money but ethics and moral values as well. A citizenry with these attributes will make a nation great.



bong067

This is a great article…allow me to share my experience: since we just had our Christmas gifts, money received by my kids goes directly to the bank…as early as 7 years old, i helped my kids open their bank accounts and show them how their money grow…they have fun saving, since they compete (siblings). Now that they are teen agers, the habit of saving is already within them, everytime there is a need to buy “luho” they save money and never asked money from me…



Millionaire Acts

Nice article. I think that we really should instill to them that saving is really indeed needed for their future. We can also open a bank account for them so they would have a literal figure that they can track.



Comments

Please Leave a Comment!




Please note: Comments may be moderated. It may take a while for them to show on the page.





Welcome to
Money Smarts, where people can talk freely about personal finance, business, financial independence, the economy and my personal favorite, giving the rat race a kick on the butt. INQUIRER.net business has the floor, but you can freely ask questions and take the mic.
Disclaimer: Readers are solely responsible for their investment decisions; conduct proper due diligence and obtain professional advice. Money Smarts will not be liable for any loss or damage caused by a reader's reliance on information obtained from this blog. Money Smarts receives no compensation of any kind from any company or individual mentioned.
INQUIRER.net VDO

Search

Archives
Categories