By Tessa R. Salazar
Philippine Daily Inquirer
(First of two parts)
INQUIRER MOTORING receives letters and phone calls from readers relating their casa (manufacturers’ service center) horror stories from time to time. Usually, it’s the complainants’ word against the car manufacturer. In the hope that our motoring public (and other car manufacturers, as well) would pick up a few lessons from these “sob stories,” we will be printing them — sans real name and company name of the parties involved, of course.
The aberrant alternator
Adela dela Cruz (not her real name) relates that her five-year-old, 2-liter 4×4 A/T SUV engine suddenly turned off and wouldn’t restart. Thinking that her two-year-old battery conked out, Dela Cruz changed it. To her dismay, the battery indicator, let alone the engine, still wouldn’t turn on.
Dela Cruz brought her vehicle to the casa and was given a quotation of P42,566 to cover the cost of the labor and parts for replacing what the shop said was a problem involving the entire alternator assembly
The technical department explained that the vehicle’s alternator assembly malfunctioned. She was told that since the warranty had lapsed, she had no choice but to shoulder the cost. She later found out that the alternator wouldn’t malfunction without a cause.
“We tried to gather information from friends and friends of friends who owned the same car model, and true enough, from inside sources, they had had several complaints that year involving the same parts,” she said.
In an e-mail to Inquirer Motoring, she wrote that the cause of the problem was the defective design or placement of the alternator — the reason the new model’s design had been changed. She added that what the other owners did with those that had the same problems fixed by the casa was to put an insulator to merely delay its inevitable malfunction.
Dela Cruz added that the engine manufacturer claimed “a four-year lifespan of an alternator assembly was acceptable and normal.” She retorted that her other SUV, which was already 10 years old, still had its original alternator running well and never replaced, and her friend’s SUV, also 10 years old, still had its original alternator assembly intact.
Dela Cruz lamented that she has had to resort to the media to air her complaints, as her calls to the Department of Trade and Industry consumer complaint hotlines and her e-mails to DTI NCR have never gotten a response or even an acknowledgment.
Hot under the hood
Another complaint comes from an owner of an overheating eight-year-old mini SUV (odometer reading: 55,000 km).
After driving it into the casa for the routine 55,000-km checkup and to have the overheating fixed, she was informed by the customer service staff that the additional work would cost P78,700.
Included in the cost was the replacement of the front shock absorbers, and some other work which she claimed the same casa had already completed last year. She recalled that her bill reached over P40,000 last year for such replacements.
She was then faxed a revised quote, deleting the cost of the front shock absorbers, reducing the total additional cost to just over P64,000. By then, however, she said she was already becoming suspicious, so she informed the casa’s customer service via SMS to hold all the work for her SUV, for which she received an SMS (text) confirmation.
A friend recommended another service center in the Alabang area. There, she got a quote of P14,530 for the radiator assembly replacement, compared to the casa’s P37,783.22 charge for the same work. She made an appointment to bring her car in first thing in the morning the following day.
The Alabang shop’s customer service representative explained the work they did on her SUV, showed her the replaced radiator and the new one they installed. She was told that radiators had an average life span of four years. Hers lasted almost eight years.
She was also told that her front and rear shocks, indeed, needed to be replaced.
“Considering I just drove 10,000 km in the 12 months since the shocks were replaced — I cannot understand how I could have busted my shocks that quickly unless I got substandard, defective shock absorbers in the first place. And how can I get substandard parts from the casa. Am I not paying premium just to make sure I do not get ripped off?” she asked.
Her final bill at the Alabang service center, which included radiator, coolant, hose clamp, shop materials, labor with pressure test and with VAT included was P8,548.59. The entire radiator assembly didn’t need to be replaced, after all.
This complainant sent Inquirer Motoring the detailed list of parts quotations from both the casa and the Alabang service center. Both claimed they were using original parts.